You’ve followed the label, held the knob down for the full minute, watched the little blue flame catch, and let go. It flickers and disappears. When a water heater pilot light won’t stay lit, it’s frustrating, but it’s also one of the more informative failures a gas water heater has, because the moment it goes out narrows the cause down a long way.

This guide covers gas tank water heaters with a pilot. Furnaces use a similar safety system with their own quirks, which are covered separately in why a furnace pilot light goes out.

If You Smell Gas, Stop Here

If you smell gas before you start, or the smell builds while you’re trying to relight, stop. Don’t try to light anything, don’t use switches or phones near the heater, and leave the house. Call Southwest Gas or 911 from outside.

Everything else in this guide assumes there’s no gas smell.

How a Pilot Knows to Stay Lit

A small metal probe sits in the pilot flame. On most standard tank heaters it’s a thermocouple; some use a thermopile, which works the same way but makes more voltage. When the flame heats the probe, it produces a tiny electrical current that holds the gas valve open. If the flame goes out or the probe stops working, the current drops and the valve shuts off the gas so it can’t pour unburned into your garage.

That’s why you hold the knob down while lighting. You’re keeping the gas flowing by hand until the probe is hot enough to take over. Nearly every pilot problem comes back to one of three things: the flame isn’t heating the probe properly, the probe isn’t producing enough current, or gas isn’t reaching the pilot in the first place.

Goes Out the Moment You Let Go

This is the classic sign of a thermocouple problem.

First, rule out technique. Many labels say to keep holding the knob for up to a minute after the pilot lights. Releasing early is the most common reason a healthy pilot goes out. Try once more, holding it for the full time the label gives.

If it still won’t stay lit, the likely causes are:

  • A worn-out thermocouple. They fail with age and heat, and can’t make enough current.
  • A thermocouple out of position. The tip needs to sit in the pilot flame. If it has been knocked aside, the flame doesn’t heat it enough.
  • A loose connection where the thermocouple screws into the gas control valve.
  • A failing gas control valve. Less common, but if a new thermocouple doesn’t solve it, this is next.

Thermocouples are small, simple parts, but on most modern heaters the burner sits behind a sealed combustion chamber door with a gasket. Getting to it means removing the burner assembly and resealing the door correctly afterward, which is why it’s a job for a technician.

Stays Lit for a While, Then Dies

When the pilot lasts minutes, hours or a day or two before going out, the flame itself is usually the problem.

A weak or dirty pilot flame. A healthy pilot is steady and mostly blue, wrapping around the tip of the thermocouple. A small, flickering or yellow flame points to a partly clogged pilot tube or orifice, often from dust or spider webs. It may heat the thermocouple just enough to stay lit for a while, then fade out.

Drafts. A heater near a garage door, an open window or an exterior vent can have its pilot blown out on windy days. If the pilot seems to go out when the weather turns gusty, that’s the clue. Resist the urge to tape cardboard around the heater or cover the vent to block the wind. Anything that restricts air to a gas burner can cause incomplete combustion, which is a bigger problem than the draft.

Venting problems. The flue on top of the heater has to carry exhaust up and out. If it’s blocked, disconnected or poorly sloped, exhaust can spill back around the burner and starve the pilot of oxygen. That also puts carbon monoxide into the space around the heater, so this cause isn’t one to ignore. Look at the vent pipe: it should be firmly connected at the top of the tank, with no gaps, rust-through or sagging sections. Any doubt, turn the gas control off and book a repair, and consider indoor air quality testing, which includes carbon monoxide detection.

Won’t Relight at All

Many newer gas water heaters are built with flammable vapor ignition resistant (FVIR) designs. They have a sealed combustion chamber, an air intake screen at the base, and safety devices that shut the heater down if they detect flammable vapors or overheating in the chamber. When one of those trips, the pilot may refuse to light or stay lit no matter what you do.

Dusty or clogged air intake screen. The screen at the bottom of the heater lets combustion air in. In a garage, where desert dust, lint from a nearby dryer and debris collect, that screen can clog. Starved of air, the pilot struggles or the heater shuts itself down. With the gas control turned off and the heater cool, you can gently vacuum the outside of the screen. Don’t remove covers or poke anything into the chamber.

Flammable vapors nearby. Gasoline, paint thinner, solvents and some cleaners stored near the heater can set off the vapor sensor. Move them well away, ventilate the area, and only try relighting once the space is clear of fumes.

A tripped thermal cutoff or locked-out sensor. On some heaters, a lockout clears on its own once conditions are normal. On others, the device has to be reset or replaced. Some heaters with electronic gas controls blink a status light to show what tripped, with a key on the label. Either way, a heater that has locked itself out has done so for a reason, and finding that reason is technician work.

The Gas Isn’t Getting There

Sometimes the heater is fine and the gas just isn’t arriving.

Check the handle on the gas line leading into the heater. It should be parallel to the pipe. Then check another gas appliance. If the stove and furnace don’t work either, the problem is the gas supply to the house, and Southwest Gas is the one to call.

If the gas to the house was recently turned off and back on, for meter work or a repair, air can be left in the line. It sometimes takes a few attempts for gas to reach the pilot. A couple of tries is fine. Repeatedly holding the knob down and clicking the igniter for minutes on end is not.

Safe for You, and Where to Stop

Fine to do yourself: relight by following the label exactly, check the gas handle and other gas appliances, move flammable products away, clear dust from the outside of the air intake screen with the gas off, and look over the vent pipe from the outside.

Leave to a technician: replacing a thermocouple or thermopile, cleaning the pilot orifice, anything inside the sealed combustion chamber, gas control valves, resetting FVIR safety devices, and any venting repair.

If the pilot has failed twice after you’ve done the safe checks, stop relighting it. Each attempt sends a little more gas through a system that is telling you something is wrong.

Getting the Flame Back for Good

The timing of the outage points to the cause, and the safe checks above solve the simpler cases. For anything that needs the combustion chamber opened, Dr. Cool’s water heater repair service can diagnose it, usually the same day. Book online or call (702) 873-1800, and if you ever suspect a gas leak or a venting problem after hours, Dr. Cool’s emergency service answers 24/7.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it dangerous if my water heater pilot keeps going out?

The pilot going out on its own isn’t dangerous, because the thermocouple shuts off the gas when the flame disappears. The risk comes from the reasons behind it, such as a venting problem spilling exhaust, or from repeatedly relighting a heater with a fault. If anyone in the home has headaches or dizziness near the heater, get outside and call 911.

How long does a thermocouple last?

There’s no set lifespan. Many last for years, but heat, a pilot flame that’s slightly off, and age all wear them down. A heater that needs one replaced every year or two often has an underlying flame or venting problem worth investigating.

Can I leave the pilot off and just use cold water for a while?

Yes, if there’s no gas smell. Turn the gas control to Off and the heater will simply stop heating. Just know that the tank will cool over the next day or so, and plan for the repair before you need hot water again.

Why does my pilot light look yellow?

A yellow, lazy pilot usually means it isn’t getting the right mix of gas and air, often because the pilot orifice or air intake is partly blocked. Besides heating the thermocouple poorly, a yellow flame can produce soot and more carbon monoxide, so have it cleaned and adjusted.

Why does the pilot keep going out after a new thermocouple was fitted?

Then the thermocouple probably wasn’t the whole story. The new one may not be sitting squarely in the flame, the pilot orifice may be partly blocked so the flame is too weak to heat it, or the gas control valve may be failing to hold. A technician can measure the thermocouple’s output with the pilot lit, which tells them which of those it is.